Montana Mike's vs. Texas Land & Cattle

[motravelerken]

If I had to choose one steakhouse to eat at in Branson, which one would it be? Or would I be better off just going to Lone Star (which I love, but I would prefer to avoid the chain restaurants). It seems like Montana Mike's and Texas Land & Cattle are the 2 popular local ones. Is there one I am leaving out? Is Shorty Smalls in this same class of food? I am not talking about BBQ here and I already plan on going to Chester's and Danna's. I am talking about a steakhouse.

[shis1]

I used to be a fan of Lone Star Steakhouse, but it seems like their quality has gone down.......The one that we used to frequent in KC has closed. I"ve never been to Texas Land and Cattle, but have always had the impression that it might be rated a 'star or 2' better than Lone Star??????

[God's Girl]

Four of us ate at Montana Mike's the last time we were in Branson over Memorial Day weekend. Out of the four of us, my steak was the only one that wasn't overcooked. Mine was good. Everyone else said they wouldn't go back. I've never eaten at Texas Land and Cattle, but my daughter said it was very good.

[randjm]

I've been to Lone Star, Montana Mike's and Shorty Smalls. I agree with the poster about Lone Star going downhill. The drinks even seem watered down. I think Montana Mike's had more to choose from then Shorty Smalls but, at both, the food was good and their prices close to the same.

[ggh]

I was not impressed with Montana Mikes - steaks were over cooked, baked potato was cold.........

Texas Land and Cattle is a chain, but everything we've eaten there has been exceptional. MMmm!

My vote would be Texas Land and Cattle hands down.

[SHOW GAL]

I guess I am outnumbered, but I prefer Lone Star. I like my steak cooked rare and they are able to get it as rare as I like. Their filet is my favorite.

Shorty Snall's has good foor but, as far as steaks go, I wouldn't put them in the same class with the three steak houses mentioned in this post.

Hope whichever you pick, you will get a great steak. Let us know which you picked and how you liked it.

[Jalva2]

Count me in the group that wasn't impressed with Montana Mike's. Haven't tried the other places.

[Ms_Terese]

I'd go with Texas Land & Cattle. Montana Mike's hasn't impressed me much.

[SweetSue]

I have eaten at Montana Mike's once, and I was not impressed. Obvious since I haven't been back! We eat at Texas Land and Cattle every time we come to Branson. They have good food and very good service. The last time we ate there (our wedding anniversary) the manager felt we had to wait too long, so our lunch was on him! Very nice of him since we insisted that he didn't need to do that. They have gone out of their way on two separate occasions to accommodate us. Highly recommend the restaurant.

[CLUCKINGHEN]

I didn't care for Texas Land & Cattle, ordered ribeye medium and it came out well done, however, i told the waiter and i didn't have to pay for it but they did charge me for my drink. I don't think i will go there again. In my opinion you might try Charlies Steak, Rib & Ale, we love this place they have an excellent ribeye.

[bransoncutie]

If I'm going to go to Montana Mike's, I opt for the one on 248. Always have had better food and beter service at that location. I used to love Lone Star, but their food and service have both gone south in the last 2 or 3 years. I've been to Texas Land & Cattle once, but I was quite impressed. Honestly, I was not too impressed with Charlies the last time I was there either. Maybe I'm just getting too picky with my steaks these days!

[Ms_Terese]

Originally Posted by bransoncutie

Maybe I'm just getting too picky with my steaks these days!

I was thinking that same thing! I love getting steaks for us at home, because DH is fabulous on the grill, and I can use whatever seasonings or marinade I want......they always turn out so yummy! I hardly ever eat steak in restaurants anymore! (Except for a good prime rib, and that's hard to find anywhere!)

[biscuitcreek]

Usually when we go to Branson we're camping so when we want a steak, we go to Harter House in Hollister or Kimberling City and buy some steaks and grill them. Haven't ever been disappointed. So if you're staying in a condo or camping and have access to a grill, I'd recommend you buy a steak at Harter House and grill it yourself.